HomeBest of 202412 Best Bumper Plates in 2024: Top Picks for Rubber and Urethane...

12 Best Bumper Plates in 2024: Top Picks for Rubber and Urethane Plates

Garage Gym Lab is independent and supported by readers. We may earn commissions if you buy through our links.

Bumper plates are some of the most common types of weight plates that you can buy. They’re versatile, quiet, durable, and they look great.

Weight plates are an essential piece of gym equipment for anyone looking to strength train, and bumper plates are a great option.

We’ve tested every type of bumper plate, including crumb bumpers, training bumpers, competition bumpers, and urethane bumpers. We’ve used them on deadlifts, overhead drops, and more to check their bounce, durability, sound, etc. Here are some of the factors we considered (more below):

  • Bounce: What is the durometer rating of the plate? How high do they bounce?
  • Durability: Are they plates built with high-quality rubber or urethane? Do they warp or bend? How are the inserts secured?
  • Accuracy: How accurate are the plates to their stated weight?

In this article, I’ll share our picks for the best bumper plates for different lifting styles, price points, and more. Whether you’re looking for basic rubber bumper plates or premium competition plates, we’ve got you covered.

The Best Bumper Plates

Rogue Echo Bumper Plates – Best Overall Black Bumper Plates

Best Overall Black Bumper Plates
Rogue Echo Bumper Plates

The Rogue Echo Bumper Plates are some of the most popular and well-reviewed plates on the market. They're very budget-friendly with solid performance and specs.

Key Specs

  • Price: $190 (45 lb Pair)
  • Material: Virgin Rubber w/ Stainless Insert
  • Weight System: Pounds
  • Weight Options: 10-45 lb (also available in 160-560 lb sets)
  • Weight Tolerance: +/- 1%
  • Collar Opening: 50.6mm (1.99″)
  • Durometer Rating: 88 (Low-to-Medium Bounce)
  • Warranty: 90 Days on 10-15 lbs & 3 Years on 25 lb+


CHECK PRICE

Summary

The Rogue Echo v2 bumper plates are some of the most popular rubber plates on the market given their price and performance. They’re simple, attractive, accurate, and approved for the Army Combat Fitness Test (ACFT).

The Rogue Echo Bumpers all offer a durometer rating of 88 from 10lb-45lb, which creates a medium-to-low bounce. The plates are constructed with virgin rubber and they offer a stainless steel center ring. This ring measures 50.6mm, which is common for a plate of this style. The virgin rubber helps contribute to a lower bounce and it reduces the smell compared to recycled rubber, although some owners have still complained about it.

Rogue Echo Bumper Plates - Best Bumper Plates

One of the best features of the Echo plates is that they have a weight tolerance of +/- 1%. They’re also among the thinnest cheap bumper plates around, which is a big benefit if you’re a big lifter. This will allow for up to 590lbs of plates on a traditional barbell depending on the collar you’re using.

Another nice feature of these is that they’re approved for the ACFT, which is a 6-event assessment for Army combat readiness. These plates can be purchased in pairs or sets, and they can also be purchased in color. These colored bumper plates are slightly thinner than even the Black Echo plates. In terms of aesthetics, the black version includes a matte black finish with contrasting white lettering. They’re a sharp-looking plate with a simple overall aesthetic.

Overall, if you’re looking for basic black bumper plates, the Rogue Echos are our top pick. Their price-to-performance ratio is one of the strongest out there.

Pros

  • Great value for plates with a longstanding reputation as being high-quality
  • Stainless steel inner ring
  • +/- 1% accuracy
  • Approved for Army Combat Fitness Test
  • Contrasting white lettering helps for quick weight identification
  • 3 available set options

Cons

  • Some owners have complained about the smell

Fringe Sport Color Bumper Plates – Best Overall Color Bumper Plates

Best Overall Color Bumper Plates
Fringe Sport Color Bumper Plates

The Fringe Sport Color Bumper Plates are affordable, high-performing bumpers with a very strong reputation.

Key Specs

  • Price: $279 (45 lb Pair) w/ Free Shipping
  • Material: Virgin Rubber w/ Stainless Insert
  • Weight System: Pounds
  • Weight Options: 10-55 lb (also available in 100-370 lb sets)
  • Weight Tolerance: +/- 1%
  • Collar Opening: 50.4mm (1.98″)
  • Durometer Rating: 90 on 10-15 lb plates; 85 on 25 lb+ (Low-to-Medium Bounce)
  • Warranty: 3 Years on 25 lb+ & 1-Year on 10-15 lb


CHECK PRICE

Summary

These Fringe Sport Bumper Plates are a great choice for someone looking for quality colored bumpers at a solid price. Having owned nearly all the plate styles that Fringe Sport offers, I can attest to their quality, value, and overall performance.

These plates have a hooked stainless steel insert that works to increase the durability of the plate. Some plates with a simple pressed insert will dislodge over time or warp sooner. These plates have a very strong reputation with hundreds of verified reviews dating back to their release in 2014. In the home gym, you can be confident they’ll last years and withstand constant abuse thanks to how they’re constructed.

The Fringe Sport Color Bumpers are made with virgin rubber and they offer a low-to-medium bounce. The 25lb+ variants carry a durometer rating of 85 while the 10lb and 15lb variants carry a rating of 90. The tolerances on these plates are very tight. In terms of weight, they are guaranteed to +/- 1%, which I can again verify on my set. In terms of the hole opening, it measures 50.4mm, which produces a very snug fit that reduces vibration and noise.

Fringe Sport Color Bumper Plates - Best Bumper Plates

The diameters of these plates are also consistently 450mm, except for the 10lb plates. These were purposely built to 445mm to limit them warping over time. Because the 10lb plates are the thinnest, they’re prone to “Taco” if dropped and met with the ground. By having them slightly smaller, when they’re on the bar with other plates, they don’t meet the ground. Therefore, they last a lot longer. Furthermore, their 10lb and 15lb plates carry a 1-year warranty, which is longer than many others that offer 3-6 months. Heavier variants carry a strong 3-year warranty.

One thing to consider is that these Fringe Sport bumper plates have a slightly thicker profile than some competing plates. For example, the 45lb plate has a thickness of 2.9″ whereas the Rogue Echos are 2.36″ and the REP Color Bumpers are 2.8″. This will only pose an issue if you’re nearing max capacity, but it’s something worth noting nonetheless.

Pros

  • With free shipping, these plates offer a very nice value
  • Stainless steel inner ring
  • +/- 1% accuracy
  • Numerous set options
  • Solid warranty

Cons

  • Durometer rating on 25lb+ is less than 10-15lb
  • Thicker than some plates of similar style

Rogue Competition Bumper Plates – Best Overall Competition Bumper Plates

Best Competition Plates
Rogue Competition Plates

The Rogue Competition Plates are extremely accurate, high-quality, and beautiful bumper plates. They're ideal for serious lifters

Key Specs

  • Price: $335 (45 lb Pair)
  • Material: Virgin Rubber w/ Full Hard Chrome Hub
  • Weight System: Pounds & Kilograms
  • Weight Options: 25-55 lb & 10-25 kg (also available in sets)
  • Weight Tolerance: +/- 15 grams
  • Collar Opening: 50.4mm (1.98″)
  • Durometer Rating: 94 (Low Bounce)
  • Warranty: 5 Years


CHECK PRICE

Summary

The Rogue Competition Bumper Plates are some of the nicest overall plates on the market. These were the very first plates I ever purchased for my home gym. I’ve owned them since 2016 and they’ve held up tremendously after years of use.

Competition plates are known for being the most accurate type of bumper plate. These are accurate to within +/- 15 grams. I’ve weighed all 10 of mine and all are within this guaranteed tolerance. These plates are available in pounds (what I have) or in Kilograms. The Kilogram version is approved by the IWF to be used in international weightlifting competitions and they include an attractive IWF logo. In addition to the weight tolerance, the collar opening is also very tight at 50.4mm, which creates a snug fit on the bar.

Rogue Competition Bumper Plates - Best Bumper Plates

These plates have a very high durometer rating of 94, which is among the highest in the entire industry. This creates an exceptionally low bounce. They include a full-sized center hub with a hard chrome finish. This increases the durability of the plates while also looking beautiful. These plates also have a very thin profile, which is a general benefit of competition bumper plates. This means you can load more weight onto the bar relative to some other bumpers.

The colors on these plates are bright and very aesthetically pleasing. I love the raised lettering and contrasting white text. Keep in mind that, while the chrome hubs look beautiful, they will show blemishes more than zinc, so the occasional wipe-down may be necessary. Rogue does include raised flanges around the hub to prevent metal-on-metal contact, which certainly helps.

If you’re training for competition, if you require thin plates, if you demand tight tolerances, or if you just like top-flight equipment, these are an excellent option. They’re the best Rogue bumper plates available.

Read our Full Rogue Competition Bumpers Review

Pros

  • Very accurate
  • Durometer rating of 94 creates a very low bounce
  • Available in pounds and kilograms (IWF-Certified)
  • Thinner profile compared to traditional bumper plates
  • Great warranty

Cons

  • Chrome center hub will show fingerprints, smudges, and imperfections more than zinc
  • Expensive for the average home gym owner

American Barbell Pro Urethane Bumper Plates – Best Overall Urethane Bumper Plates

Best Urethane Plates
American Barbell Urethane Plates

The American Barbell Urethane Plates are premium bumper plates with a beautiful aesthetic and excellent performance.

Key Specs

  • Price: $473 (45 lb Pair)
  • Material: Urethane w/ Hard Chrome Hub
  • Weight System: Pounds & Kilograms
  • Weight Options: 25-55 lb & 10-25 kg
  • Weight Tolerance: N/A
  • Collar Opening: 50.4mm (1.98″)
  • Durometer Rating: N/A (Low Bounce)
  • Warranty: 3 Years


CHECK PRICE

Summary

Like the Rogue Competition Plates above, the American Barbell Urethane Bumpers were some of the first plates I added to my home gym. In my opinion, these are the nicest-looking plates available and they offer very strong performance to boot.

Urethane has a few advantages over rubber. One being it’s more durable, two being it’s more customizable with color/logo, and three being that it’s odorless. Ultimately, most home gym owners will find urethane plates to be a luxury item. Unless you’re hitting a ton of volume with a lot of frequency, you’re unlikely to achieve the durability benefits over rubber bumper plates in a home gym. In a commercial setting, the case for urethane is stronger, especially with the customization possibilities.

American Barbell Pro Urethane Bumper Plates - Best Bumper Plates

One disadvantage of urethane relative to rubber is that it’s slicker, which can make it more challenging to handle the plates. The pebble grain surface looks amazing, but it doesn’t do much in way of generating friction to alleviate this “issue.” One other thing to note is that I’ve found the collar openings on urethane plates, in general, to be tighter than even competition rubber bumpers. This is good and bad. On one hand, it reduces noise and vibration during lifts. On the other hand, it can be louder sliding the plates on and off and it can cause more imperfections on certain sleeve finishes, namely Cerakote.

I have personally not found a better-looking plate than the American Barbell Urethane Bumpers. They’re stunning plates with very vibrant colors. An interesting thing about them, however, is that the LB plates don’t have the weight callout, whereas the KG plates do. I’m not sure why this is the case, but the KG plates do look nicer because of that, in my opinion. The center hub is hard chrome and it’s smooth, which differs from some other urethane plates that have indented hubs. I prefer the American Barbell hub style from a visual perspective.

While American Barbell doesn’t claim a weight tolerance or a durometer rating, my experience shows an accuracy of +/- 1% and a low bounce. If you’re looking for urethane plates and you have a big budget, these are hard to beat. Check down below for some less expensive options.

Read our Full American Barbell Urethane Bumpers Review

Pros

  • Possibly the best-looking plates on the market
  • Urethane is more durable than rubber
  • Available in pounds or kilograms
  • Tight collar opening creates a very snug fit
  • Very low bounce

Cons

  • Not sold in sets
  • Urethane is slicker/harder to grip than rubber
  • Expensive for the average home gym owner

Vulcan Alpha Bumper Plates – Most Versatile Bumper Plates

Most Versatile Bumpers
Vulcan Alpha Bumper Plates

The Vulcan Alpha Bumper Plates are uniquely-designed plates for indoor and outdoor use. They're very durable, low-bounce, and well-reviewed.

Key Specs

  • Price: $214.99 (45 lb Pair)
  • Material: Virgin Rubber w/ Stainless Insert
  • Weight System: Pounds
  • Weight Options: 10-55 lb (also available in 160-1,000 lb sets)
  • Weight Tolerance: +/- 1%
  • Collar Opening: 50.6mm (1.99″)
  • Durometer Rating: 89 (Low Bounce)
  • Warranty: 4 Years on 35 lb+, 3 Years on 25 lb, & 1 Year on 10-15 lb


CHECK PRICE

Summary

The Vulcan Alpha Bumper Plates are very unique in terms of their aesthetic and their function. The best feature of these plates is that they’ve been designed to be used indoors and outdoors on a variety of surfaces. This can include concrete, asphalt, rubber flooring, and many others.

The Alphas have a durometer rating of 89 on all plates, which is high for non-competition bumper plates. This creates a low bounce that you can see firsthand in the video above. They’re also guaranteed to be within a +/- 1% weight tolerance, so you can rest assured you’ll be lifting very close to the stated weight.

Vulcan Alpha Bumper Plates - Best Weight Plates

Vulcan claims that these plates offer a noise reduction of ~25% when dropped from 9 feet. This appears to be compared to recycled rubber plates like Hi-Temps, which have poor tolerances that can lead to excess noise. In my experience, the Alphas are similar to other high-end bumper plates when it comes to noise.

Vulcan was one of the first companies to offer the flecked pattern on bumper plates. Originating in 2015, this design is fun, unique, and it’s still based on the IWF color scheme. Each plate is different in terms of its fleck pattern. Other fleck plates on the market, while looking similar, don’t offer the same versatility as the Vulcan’s given their indoor/outdoor design.

Alpha Bumper Plates by Vulcan Strength

The center ring is hooked into the bumper to increase durability and overall life expectancy. Vulcan is so confident in this design that they offer a 4-year warranty on 35lb+, 3 years on 25lb, and 1 year on 10-15lb variants. This is one of the best warranties in the industry for rubber bumper plates.

If you like the unique fleck design and you see value in the indoor/outdoor capabilities, the Vulcan Alphas are a great buy.

Pros

  • Can be used on a variety of surfaces both indoors and outdoors
  • High durometer rating
  • Numerous set options
  • Outstanding warranty without use restrictions
  • Fleck design creates a unique look

Cons

  • Wider profile than most virgin rubber bumper plates
  • Collar opening is not as tight as some other bumper plates

REP Black Bumper Plates – Runner-Up Black Bumper Plates

Runner-Up Black Bumpers
REP Black Bumper Plates

The REP Black Bumper Plates are a great budget-friendly option for basic plates with solid performance and user feedback.

Key Specs

  • Price: $209.99 w/ Free Shipping (45 lb Pair)
  • Material: Virgin Rubber w/ Steel Insert
  • Weight System: Pounds
  • Weight Options: 5-45 lb (also available in 160-370 lb sets)
  • Weight Tolerance: +/- 3%
  • Collar Opening: 50.4mm (1.98″)
  • Durometer Rating: N/A (Medium Bounce)
  • Warranty: 6 Months on 10-15 lbs & 3 Years on 25 lb+


CHECK PRICE

Summary

The REP Black bumper plates are a very solid choice if you’re looking for a basic set of bumpers. These plates are accurate, they look nice, and they’re durable.

These bumpers from REP Fitness have a guaranteed weight tolerance of +/- 1%, which is common for plates of this style. Considering these plates used to be +/- 3%, it’s a welcomed change that puts them firmly in the conversation among their competition.

While these plates don’t have a stated durometer rating like some others, in my experience, they offer a very similar bounce as similar plates. This medium bounce likely puts the durometer in the 85-90 range. While it would be nice for them to have this spec referenced, you can rest assured it’s on par with others.

REP Black Bumpers - Best Bumper Plates

The center ring is not stainless steel, but it does have hooked inserts, which greatly help increase the durability of the plates. They’ve also beefed up the 10lb plates with additional thickness to discourage warping. The 45lb plates are 2.83″ thick, which falls somewhere in the middle on the spectrum of similar plates. This allows for over 500lbs of weight.

The REP black bumpers have raised white lettering, which contrasts nicely to quickly identify plates. In terms of warranty, these plates have a very competitive 3-year warranty on 25lb plates and a better-than-most 6-month warranty on 10-15lbs.

Pros

  • Accurate to +/- 1% guaranteed weight tolerance
  • Hooked inserts increase durability
  • Available in a 5lb variation for technique training
  • White contrast raised lettering
  • Wide range of set options

Cons

  • Warranty is void if mixed with Hi-Temp plates
  • No stated durometer rating
  • Center ring is not stainless steel

Rogue Fleck Bumper Plates – Runner-Up Color Bumper Plates

Runner-Up Color Bumpers
Rogue Fleck Plates

The Rogue Fleck Plates offer a unique and fun patterned design with strong specs and performance.

Key Specs

  • Price: $205 (45 lb Pair)
  • Material: Virgin Rubber w/ Stainless Insert
  • Weight System: Pounds
  • Weight Options: 10-55 lb (also available in 160-350 lb sets)
  • Weight Tolerance: +/- 1%
  • Collar Opening: 50.4mm (1.98″)
  • Durometer Rating: 90 (Low Bounce)
  • Warranty: 2 Years


CHECK PRICE

Summary

The Rogue Fleck Plates became an instant classic during the heart of quarantine due to the fact they were in stock more than many other plates. It turns out they’re great plates in general, which has resulted in them being some of the more reviewed Rogue Fitness bumper plates.

The first thing you’ll notice about these plates is their interesting and fun fleck pattern. The colors are bright and they’re coded to the IWF color scheme for easy identification. Each plate has a different pattern, so no plate will be the same in terms of looks. The contrasting white lettering provides a nice pop and the text is very legible.

Rogue Fleck Plates - Best Bumper Plates

One of the best features of the Rogue Fleck Plates is the high durometer rating of 90 on all variants. This results in a very low bounce that you would normally find on urethane and competition-level bumper plates. They also have a relatively thin profile (2.76″ on 45’s), which allows for plenty of weight on the bar for most people.

The center ring is stainless steel and it measures 50.4mm for a very snug fit. These plates are guaranteed to +/- 1% on weight accuracy and they offer a full two-year warranty on all variants, which includes 10-15lbs.

While the Rogue Fleck Plates weren’t designed to be used outdoors like the similar-looking Vulcan Alphas, they are less expensive. As such, they’re a strong contender if you’re looking for fleck-style/unique plates.

Pros

  • Fleck pattern provides and unique and fun look
  • High durometer rating of 90 on all plate variants
  • Stainless steel inner ring
  • +/- 1% weight accuracy
  • Four set options are available

Cons

  • 2-year warranty is very strong on 10-15lb variants, but not as strong on 25lb+ plates

REP Competition Bumper Plates – Runner-Up Competition Bumper Plates

Runner-Up Competition Plates
REP Competition Plates

The REP Competition Bumper Plates are highly accurate and thin plates with a full center hub for durability and a low bounce.

Key Specs

  • Price: $299.99 w/ Free Shipping (45 lb Pair)
  • Material: Virgin Rubber w/ Full Zinc Hub
  • Weight System: Pounds and Kilograms
  • Weight Options: 25-55 lb & 10-25 kg (also available in lb sets and kg sets)
  • Weight Tolerance: +/- 10 grams
  • Collar Opening: 50.5mm (1.98″)
  • Durometer Rating: 92 (Low Bounce)
  • Warranty: 5 Years


CHECK PRICE

Summary

The REP Fitness Competition Bumper Plates are some of the best comp plates that you can buy for the money. They’re very well-spec’d, in some areas better than Rogue, and they’re very strong performers.

One of the biggest benefits of competition bumpers is the thinner profile relative to other styles. With the 45’s measuring only 2.125″ thick, you can load nearly 700lbs on the bar with these plates. In addition, they’re very accurate with a guaranteed weight tolerance of +/- 10 grams. This is better than the Rogue Competition Bumper Plates (15 grams) and on par with some of the most high-end plates on the market.

REP Competition Plates - Best Bumper Plates

The REP comp plates have a very high durometer rating of 92, which creates a very low bounce. This isn’t as high as the Rogue plates (94), but it is higher than most other comp plates out there (90). They also have a full zinc hub, which is very common. While they may not look as good as chrome, they do hide smudges, fingerprints, etc… better than chrome. Full-size hubs generally increase the durability of a plate significantly. These competition plates from REP have been factory tested to over 30,000 drops from 8 feet.

You can purchase these plates in pounds or kilograms and they’re available in a variety of sets. They have a very strong warranty of 5 years. Aesthetically, these plates have a standard IWF color scheme with contrasting raised white lettering. The REP Competition Bumper Plates are beautiful plates with great specs at a very reasonable price point for this style of plate.

Pros

  • Extremely accurate to +/- 10 grams
  • 92 shore durometer rating results in a dead bounce
  • Available in pounds and kilograms
  • Very strong 5-year warranty
  • Thin profile = more weight on the bar

Cons

  • Still somewhat expensive for the average home gym owner, but free shipping sweetens the deal
  • Zinc hub is very durable and hides smudges better than chrome, but it’s visually not as vibrant

Titan Fitness Elite Bumper Plates – Best Budget Competition Bumper Plates

Best Budget Competition Plates
Titan Fitness Elite Bumper Plates

The Titan Elite Bumper Plates are great plates if you're looking for comp specs on a budget. They're accurate, nice-looking, affordable plates.

Key Specs

  • Price: $279.98 (20 kg Pair – Free Shipping)
  • Material: Rubber w/ Full Chrome Hub
  • Weight System: Kilograms
  • Weight Options: 10-25 kg (also available in sets)
  • Weight Tolerance: +/- 10 grams
  • Collar Opening: 50.6mm (1.99″)
  • Durometer Rating: N/A (Low Bounce)
  • Warranty: 1 Year


CHECK PRICE

Summary

The Titan Elite Bumper Plates are a great budget option for competition bumper plates. They’re only available in kilograms, which may be a downside to some lifters, but they have nice specs that are on par with more expensive plates.

Like other competition plates, these from Titan are thin, accurate, and very durable. The 20kg plates have a thickness of 2.16″, which allows for nearly 700lbs of bar weight. They’re also accurate to +/- 10 grams, which is the most accurate you can buy.

The plates have a full-chrome hub, which is typically reserved for higher-end plates. Most budget-friendly competition bumpers have zinc hubs. While the warranty of 1 year isn’t as strong as some other plates, there is little concern that they won’t last well beyond that in normal lifting environments.

Titan Elite Bumper Plates - Best Bumper Plates

The Titan Elite Bumpers have raised flanges around the hubs to prevent metal-on-metal contact, which is a standard for this style of plate. Combined with an ultra-low bounce and six hub bolts, these are very durable bumpers.

Aesthetically, these are nice-looking plates, but they don’t look quite as good as other competition bumpers. The colors are vibrant, but the printed lettering doesn’t look as refined as the raised lettering on others. However, the contrasting white text still pops, making them easy to identify along with the uniform color scheme.

What makes these plates so attractive, other than their solid specs, is their price. Not only are they priced well, but they’re often on sale. I recommend checking them out if you’re looking for competition bumper plates on a budget.

Pros

  • Excellent value
  • Accurate to +/- 10 grams
  • Very low bounce
  • Full-size chrome hub
  • Very thin profile

Cons

  • 1-year warranty isn’t as high as some other competition plates
  • Only available in kilograms

Vulcan Urethane Bumper Plates – Runner-Up Urethane Bumper Plates

Runner-Up Urethane Plates
Vulcan Urethane Bumper Plates

The Vulcan Urethane Bumper Plates are some of the best-looking plates on the market with strong performance to match.

Key Specs

  • Price: $284.99 (45 lb Pair)
  • Material: Urethane w/ Chrome Insert
  • Weight System: Pounds
  • Weight Options: 10-55 lb (also available in sets)
  • Weight Tolerance: +/- 1%
  • Collar Opening: 50.4mm (1.98″)
  • Durometer Rating: 90 (Low Bounce)
  • Warranty: N/A


CHECK PRICE

Summary

The Vulcan Urethane Bumper Plates were the second set of urethane plates that I added to my home gym. I’m very impressed with them, including their looks, their performance, and their price.

These plates have a high shore durometer rating of 90, which creates a low bounce that’s consistent with other urethane plates. They’re also guaranteed to be within +/- 1% of the stated weight, which is consistent with similar-style plates. Their low-profile build also allows for a higher weight load relative to thicker rubber plates.

Vulcan Urethane Bumper Plates

The center hubs on these plates are smooth hard chrome, and aside from looking great, they have a very tight tolerance. Of all the plates I’ve owned, I would say that these fit the most snug of any of them. A raised flange is included to keep the chrome looking great, although some wipe downs may be necessary to remove fingerprints, etc…

Urethane bumpers have some advantages over rubber bumper plates, including durability, color vibrancy, and low odor. These plates are extremely vibrant and aesthetically very nice-looking. I love the Vulcan logo at the bottom with the integrated weight call-out. If there’s one odd thing about these plates, however, it’s that the 35lb variants have a highlighter-like look to them, which I don’t care for. Then again, I don’t care for 35lb plates in general… a topic for another day.

Read Our Full Vulcan Urethane Plate Review

Pros

  • Beautiful, vibrant colored plates
  • Urethane is more durable than rubber
  • Center hub creates a very tight fit on the bar
  • +/- 1% accuracy
  • 90 shore durometer rating

Cons

  • Not available in kilograms or sets
  • Urethane is slicker than rubber

Titan Fitness Urethane Bumper Plates – Best Budget Urethane Bumper Plates

Best Budget Urethane Plates
Titan Urethane Bumper Plates

The Titan Fitness Urethane Plates offer tremendous value on high-quality bumpers with excellent specs and features.

Key Specs

  • Price: $339.98 (45 lb Pair – Free Shipping)
  • Material: Urethane w/ Chrome Insert
  • Weight System: Pounds and Kilograms
  • Weight Options: 10-55 lb & 5-25 kg (also available in sets)
  • Weight Tolerance: +/- 1%
  • Collar Opening: 50.6mm (1.99″)
  • Durometer Rating: Low-to-Medium Bounce
  • Warranty: 1 Year


CHECK PRICE

Summary

Like other urethane plates, these from Titan are highly durable, accurate, thin, and low-odor. They also ship for free, making them the best budget-friendly urethane plates out there.

These plates have a guaranteed weight tolerance of +/- 1%, which is industry standard for urethane plates. They’re also built to IWF specs with a 2″ collar opening and a 450mm diameter. The 2″ thickness (45lb plate) is among the lowest on the market, which is great if you’re a heavy lifter considering this is thinner than competition rubber bumper plates.

Titan Urethane Bumper Plates - Best Bumper Plates

The Titan Urethane Plates don’t claim a shore durometer rating, but they’re low bounce like others I’ve used. A great benefit of these plates is that they have a 10lb/5kg option, which not all companies offer. This variation also has a 415mm diameter, protecting them from warps due to dropping.

Aesthetically, these look similar to other high-end urethane plates with vibrant colors, raised lettering, and a chrome center hub.

All-in-all, these are great urethane plates at awesome prices when you factor in the free shipping. Considering these plates often go on sale, it’s an even better value.

Pros

  • Vibrant plates with IWF specs
  • Thin profile allows for heavier loads
  • Hard chrome center hub
  • +/- 1% accuracy
  • Available in pounds and kilograms

Cons

  • No stated durometer rating
  • Urethane is slicker than rubber

Titan Fitness Economy Bumper Plates – Best Cheap Bumper Plates

Best Cheap Bumper Plates
Titan Fitness Economy Black Bumper Plates

The Titan Fitness Economy Bumper Plates are budget-friendly, basic bumpers with a no-frills spec profile. They're well-priced and ship for free.

Key Specs

  • Price: $199.98 (45 lb Pair – Free Shipping)
  • Material: Rubber w/ Steel Insert
  • Weight System: Pounds
  • Weight Options: 10-100 lb (also available in sets)
  • Weight Tolerance: N/A
  • Collar Opening: 2″
  • Durometer Rating: N/A – Medium Bounce
  • Warranty: 1 Year


CHECK PRICE

Summary

The Economy bumper plates from Titan Fitness are basic black bumper plates with a no-frills spec profile.

The biggest benefit of these plates is their price. While they’re regularly well-priced, they’re commonly put on sale and always ship for free. It’s hard to beat them if you want basic bumper plates.

Another thing I like about these plates is that you can buy them from 10lbs to 100lbs. They don’t carry a 55lb variant, but the 100lb plate is nice for big lifters and those using plate-loaded machines.

Being budget plates, these don’t have a guaranteed weight tolerance. This is common at this price point, but you should expect +/- 3% in terms of accuracy. These also don’t state a durometer rating, but you should not expect a low bounce. They aren’t nearly as bouncy as hi-temps bumper plates, but they have a medium bounce.

The Titan Economy Bumpers are also thicker than more expensive plates, which is to be expected. The 3″ thickness on the 45lb plate is 3/4″ thinner than hi-temps and allows for ~450lbs of total bar weight.

In terms of looks, these are very basic plates with an all-black color scheme. You can upgrade to their color bumper plates if you want to add a splash of color. They’re the same plates but with an IWF color scheme.

Pros

  • Great price and free shipping
  • 100 lb variant is nice for big lifters
  • Set options are available

Cons

  • More bounce than some bumpers
  • Black on black can make it more challenging to quickly identify plates

Benefits of Bumper Plates

When it comes to picking the right plates for your gym, one of the first questions you have to ask is whether you need bumper plates or steel plates. Bumper plates offer a few primary benefits:

They’re Versatile

Bumper plates are the most versatile type of weight plate. Whether you train for Olympic weightlifting, powerlifting, CrossFit, bodybuilding, or more, bumper plates are a great choice. Steel plates, on the other hand, are mainly used for powerlifting and machine-based lifting. Unless you require specificity and/or maximum loading potential (steel plates are thinner), then I recommend bumper plates.

They’re Quiet

Another benefit of bumper plates is that they’re very quiet – much quieter than iron plates at least. In the home gym, this could play a critical factor in determining which plates to buy. If you’re concerned with noise, bumper plates are the answer.

They’re Durable

High-quality bumper plates are built to withstand thousands of drops, making them a very durable option. In the home gym, it’s realistic to expect bumper plates to last well beyond their stated warranty.

They’re Aesthetic

Bumper plates come in a variety of looks. With options for full color, all-black, contrasting lettering, color stripes, fleck patterns, etc… there is a lot to choose from based on your aesthetic preferences. They also tend to look better for longer relative to steel plates.

They’re Available at Every Budget

Bumper plates can range from budget-friendly to very high-end. While they’re generally more expensive than steel plates, there’s a bumper plate option for virtually every budget level.


Types of Bumper Plates

Vulcane Urethane Bumpers

Bumper plates come in a variety of styles based on budget, aesthetics, and most of all, performance.

Crumb Bumper Plates

Crumb bumper plates are among the most economically-priced plates available. These plates are made from recycled rubber, which emits a more potent smell than virgin rubber. Crumb bumpers are the thickest type of bumper plate, which limits how much weight you can load onto the bar. They have the lowest durometer ratings, which leads to higher bounce, and they’re not as durable as other bumper plates. If you’re on a tight budget, crumb bumper plates are a solid option, but their performance is lacking relative to others.

Black Bumper Plates

Black rubber bumper plates are also some of the most economical bumpers in terms of price. These plates generally offer a mid-80s durometer rating, which produces a medium bounce. These plates have a narrower profile than crumb bumpers, but they are noticeably thicker than competition or urethane bumper plates. Being all one color, they aren’t as easy to identify quickly, but some black bumpers will include contrasting white lettering to help. These are more durable than crumb bumpers, but less durable than competition and urethane bumpers.

Color Bumper Plates

Color rubber bumper plates are built the same as black bumpers, with the only difference being they offer colors. This typically includes a standard IWF (International Weightlifting Federation) color scheme. Some plates, like the Rogue Fleck Plate, Vulcan Alphas, Fringe Sport Savage Plates, etc… will have unique patterns, but they still maintain the overall color scheme. This makes weight identification immediate and it creates an overall nice aesthetic.

Urethane Bumper Plates

Urethane bumper plates are some of the best plates that you can buy. These plates are on the more expensive side, but they include a few advantages because of the urethane material: they have little to no odor, they have the most vibrant colors, and they’re more durable than rubber. Urethane also allows for complete customization in terms of color, logos, etc… which is a benefit for facilities or high-end home gym consumers. Urethane plates also have a low bounce.

Competition Bumper Plates

Competition Bumper Plates are the highest-tier bumper plate given their performance and IWF-spec profiles. These are among the most expensive plates available, but for good reason. Competition bumpers are extremely accurate (usually +/- 10 or 15 grams), they’re thin, and they offer the lowest bounce among bumper plates. They also have a full center hub, making them extremely durable. They’re fully colored, although some plates may be black with a colored stripe. These are called ‘training plates’, but they are often built the same as competition plates. Some competition bumper plates are officially approved by the IWF to be used in international competitions.


How to Pick Bumper Plates

American Barbell Urethane Bumpers

Here are a few of the most important factors to consider when buying bumper plates:

Training Style

One of the most important factors to consider when purchasing any piece of gym equipment is your training intention. Are you training for a weightlifting competition? If so, you should consider competition plates. Are you training for general strength & conditioning? If so, then black or colored bumper plates are a great choice.

Price

Price is another top consideration. See the FAQ section below for a breakdown of prices for different styles of bumper plates.

Durability

Different bumper plates have different levels of durability. For example, a full center hub is going to protect against warping better than a center ring. I center ring with hooks is going to protect against warping better than a simple pressed ring. Virgin rubber is going to hold up better than recycled rubber and urethane will tend to hold up better than both. Are you planning to train multiple athletes? If so, you may want to purchase plates more capable of withstanding abuse. If it’s just you, a more basic bumper will likely serve you well for a long time.

Materials

Bumper plates are made from recycled rubber, virgin rubber, or urethane. Your preferences around aesthetic, bounce, smell, price, etc… will determine which material is best for you. Similarly, hubs can include stainless steel, hard chrome, zinc, etc… While not as important beyond mainly aesthetic reasons, this is something else to consider.

Hub Style

The center hubs of bumper plates play two main roles: they influence durability and change the aesthetic of the plates. Competition bumpers, for example, have full steel hubs that are typically hard chrome or zinc. Hard chrome is beautiful, but it shows fingerprints, etc… more than the flatter look of zinc. Urethane bumpers have a medium-sized hub, typically chrome, that provides a mix of looks and durability. Basic bumpers have a smaller center ring, oftentimes which is stainless steel. I recommend hooked center rings – these anchor into the plate, which greatly increases durability and prevents the plates from warping.

Bounce

Bounce is one of the most important factors to consider when purchasing bumper plates. A low bounce means you won’t be chasing your barbell around the gym. It also makes for a more efficient experience when lifting multiple reps. The bounce is determined in large part by the shore durometer rating. This number, measured from 0-100 states the hardness of the material. High durometer ratings are correlated with a lower bounce. For example, competition bumpers have the highest durometer ratings (90+) and the lowest bounce. Crumb bumper plates, on the other hand, have the lowest durometer ratings (75-80) and the highest bounce. Basic bumpers and urethane bumpers are typically in the middle (85-90) for a medium bounce.

Thickness

Thickness is a crucial consideration if you’re a heavy lifter or if you’re using bumpers on plate-loaded machines. If either of those is true for you, you should focus on thinner bumper plates, which are generally competition bumpers or urethane bumpers. Crumb bumper plates have the thickest profiles, followed by basic black/color bumpers, and then competition/urethane bumpers.

Weight Tolerance

When you’re lifting weights, you want to lift with plates that are close to their stated weight. Competition plates will be the most accurate, often to +/- 10-15 grams. Other high-quality black/color/urethane bumpers will often have a guarantee of +/-1%. Some others will have a higher tolerance of +/-3% although they’re typically well within this range. In general, bumper plates tend to be more accurate than steel plates.

Warranty

Quality bumper plates will typically outlive their warranties under normal conditions, especially in a home gym. You will commonly see 3-5 year warranties on 25lb+ bumpers and 3 months to 1 year on 10-15lb variations.


FAQs About Bumper Plates

  • What are Bumper Plates?

    Bumper plates are a type of weight plate with a rubber outer construction and a steel center construction. Bumper plates have consistent diameters and they can be used for Olympic weightlifting, powerlifting, CrossFit, and more.

  • How Much Do Bumper Plates Cost?

    Bumper plates range in price based on their materials, lifting purpose, brand, and more. The following breaking shows a standard range on a price-per-pound basis (45lb benchmark) for bumper plates:Crumb Bumper Plates – $1.83-$2.10Black Bumper Plates – $1.75-$2.25Color Bumper Plates – $2.15-$3.10Urethane Bumper Plates – $2.55-$3.90Competition Bumper Plates – $2.85-$3.80

  • Should I Buy Bumper Plates?

    I highly recommend bumper plates because they’re the most versatile type of weight plate. Unless you’re specifically training as a powerlifter or you’re training a lot with plate-loaded machines, bumper plates will offer the most bang for your buck.

Adam Hensley
Adam Hensley
Adam is the founder of Garage Gym Lab and has over two decades of fitness/training experience. He serves as the chief content creator and runs our YouTube channel and social media accounts. When he's not testing equipment or sharing his love for home gym life, you'll find him with his wife and two kids in sunny South Carolina.
Adam Hensley
Adam Hensley
Adam is the founder of Garage Gym Lab and has over two decades of fitness/training experience. He serves as the chief content creator and runs our YouTube channel and social media accounts. When he's not testing equipment or sharing his love for home gym life, you'll find him with his wife and two kids in sunny South Carolina.

Latest Articles

Beyond Power Voltra 1 Review: Impressive Tech & Performance

Quick Overview The Beyond Power Voltra 1 is a unique, portable, high-quality cable attachment with up to 200...

Shogun NORD-EX Review (2024)

Quick Overview The Shogun NORD-EX is a posterior chain machine that allows for Nordic curls and back extensions....

REP PR-5000 Power Rack Review (2024)

Quick Overview The REP PR-5000 is a highly configurable power rack with excellent specs for home and commercial...